Glossary · Orders & execution

A-book and B-book in gold trading

A-book means a broker passes your trades to the market; B-book means it takes the other side itself, so your loss can be its profit. Many use a mix of both.

Also called A-book broker, B-book broker, Dealing desk, Hybrid model

A-book and B-book describe what a CFD broker does with your trade. In the A-book model the broker passes your order on to a liquidity provider, such as a bank or a larger dealer, and earns from the spread or a commission. In the B-book model the broker keeps the trade in-house and becomes your counterparty: if you lose, it gains, and if you win, it pays. Many brokers run a hybrid, sending some clients or large trades to the A-book and keeping the rest on the B-book.

How it applies to gold trading

XAUUSD is one of the most traded CFD products, so the model matters to gold traders. B-booking is legal in many places and is not a scam by itself, but it creates a conflict of interest, which is why good regulators require brokers to manage it and disclose it. Warning signs that a firm is fighting its clients, whatever its model, include frequent requotes on profitable trades, one-sided slippage, cancelled profits and slow withdrawals.

Worked example

Example (hypothetical numbers): you buy 1 lot (100 ounces) of XAUUSD at 4,000 and close at 4,010, a $1,000 profit. In an A-book setup, the broker earned its spread or commission whether you won or lost. In a B-book setup, your $1,000 profit is the broker’s $1,000 loss on that trade. Over thousands of clients most retail accounts lose, which is why the B-book model can be profitable for the firm.

A common mistake

Thinking an “ECN” or “STP” label proves a broker is pure A-book. Labels are marketing. Check the firm’s regulator and its order-execution policy, and judge it by how it treats withdrawals and fills.

If you are in India: offshore CFD accounts are not on RBI’s list of authorised trading platforms; read is forex trading legal in India.

See also: Liquidity provider, ECN account, CFD, Requote, Slippage.

Frequently asked questions

What does B-book mean?

A B-book broker takes the other side of your trade itself instead of passing it to the market, so your losses are its gains and your profits are its costs.

Is a B-book broker a scam?

Not by itself. It is a common, legal model in many places, but it creates a conflict of interest. Judge a firm by its regulator, its execution policy and how it handles withdrawals.

How can I tell if my broker is A-book or B-book?

You usually cannot tell for sure. Read the order-execution policy and client agreement, which must describe how orders are handled, and watch for one-sided slippage or requotes.