Brokers & safety

ECN vs STP vs Market Maker: How Your Gold Order Is Really Filled (A-Book, B-Book Explained)

Brokers describe themselves as ECN, STP, no dealing desk or market maker, and the words sound technical. Underneath, there are only two basic choices: either the broker takes the other side of your gold trade itself, or it passes your trade on to someone else. This guide explains the three models in plain words, follows one gold order through each, explains A-book and B-book, the conflicts of interest, and the questions to ask before you open an account.

Gold spot$3,528.2−99.8 (−2.75%)NextUS Q3 GDP (second estimate) and October PCE inflationin 4d 20h · Wed 13:30 GMTMarket opencloses in 4h 34mRange$123.2
Gold price, last 12 monthsGold price, last 12 monthsHigh $5,318 (29 Jan 2026) · low $3,536 (20 Nov 2026) · 12-month change −14.2%$4,000$4,500$5,000$3,536Dec ’25Feb ’26Apr ’26Jun ’26Aug ’26Oct ’26
COMEX gold, daily closes, last 12 months · data to 20 Nov 2026 · xauusdglobal.com

The short answer

There are three common broker models for gold (XAUUSD) trading:

Model Who takes the other side of your trade? Usual pricing
Market maker (dealing desk) The broker itself Wider spread, often no commission
STP (straight-through processing) Outside liquidity providers (banks, large dealers) Spread with a small markup
ECN (electronic communication network) Other participants in a network Raw spread plus a commission

STP and ECN are often grouped as no dealing desk. Behind the labels, the key question is simple: does the broker earn when you lose? If it keeps your trade on its own books (called B-book), it can. If it passes your trade on (A-book), it earns from spreads and commission instead. Many brokers mix both.

Why this matters to a gold trader

The model affects:

  • Cost: spread, commission and markups.
  • Execution: requotes, slippage and fills during news.
  • Conflict of interest: whether the broker profits from your losses.

But it is not the most important thing. A licensed, well-regulated broker of any model is safer than an unlicensed “ECN” broker. Start with how to check a broker licence, then think about the model.

Model 1: the market maker (dealing desk)

A market maker creates its own buy and sell prices and fills your order itself. When you buy 0.10 lot of gold, the broker sells it to you from its own book.

How one gold order is filled:

  1. You click Buy 0.10 lot at the ask price, say $4,000.30.
  2. The broker’s system fills you instantly. The broker is now short 10 ounces against you.
  3. The broker may keep that risk, or hedge it by buying gold elsewhere, or offset it against another client who sold.
  4. When you close, the broker buys back from you.

Good points: fast fills, often stable spreads in calm markets, small minimum sizes.

Risks: if the broker keeps your trade unhedged, your loss is its gain. That is a conflict of interest. Regulated firms must manage it under rules on fair treatment and best execution, and publish policies that explain how. Unregulated firms have no such duty.

Model 2: STP (straight-through processing)

An STP broker passes your order automatically to one or more liquidity providers, usually banks or large non-bank dealers. It adds a small markup to their price.

How one gold order is filled:

  1. You click Buy 0.10 lot.
  2. The broker’s bridge sends the order to its liquidity provider(s), who quote, say, $4,000.20 ask.
  3. The broker adds its markup, say $0.10, and you are filled at $4,000.30.
  4. The liquidity provider is the other side of your trade, not the broker.

Good points: the broker earns from your volume, not from your losses.

Risks: the markup is hidden inside the spread, and during news the liquidity provider may fill at a worse price (slippage) or reject the order (an off-quote). See requotes and off-quotes explained.

Model 3: ECN (electronic communication network)

An ECN connects your order to a network where many participants (banks, funds, other brokers’ flows) post buy and sell prices. You see something close to the raw price and pay a separate commission.

How one gold order is filled:

  1. You click Buy 0.10 lot.
  2. Your order goes to the network and is matched with the best available sell price, say $4,000.15.
  3. You are filled at $4,000.15 and pay a commission, for example $0.70 for the round trip on 0.10 lot (example number; real commissions vary).
  4. Another participant in the network is the other side.

Good points: tight raw spreads, clear costs, often better for active traders.

Risks: commission adds up; spreads can widen sharply when liquidity disappears, such as at the daily rollover or during big releases. See gold spread widening at rollover.

Note: in retail forex and CFD trading, “ECN” is often a marketing label. Many “ECN accounts” are simply raw-spread accounts at a hybrid broker. The account name does not prove how your order is filled.

A-book, B-book and hybrid brokers

These words describe what happens after you click:

  • A-book: your trade is passed to an outside party. The broker earns from spread, markup or commission.
  • B-book: your trade stays on the broker’s books. The broker takes the other side and earns when you lose (and loses when you win).
  • Hybrid: the broker decides per client or per trade. Small, new or losing accounts are often B-booked; large or consistently profitable accounts are often A-booked.

Is B-book always bad? Not necessarily. With many clients, wins and losses partly offset each other, and a regulated broker must still execute fairly. But you should know that the incentive exists.

Same trade, three models (example numbers)

One 0.10-lot round trip (buy and later sell) on gold, using example costs:

Model Spread paid Commission Total cost
Market maker $0.40 per oz × 10 oz = $4.00 $0 $4.00
STP $0.30 per oz × 10 oz = $3.00 $0 $3.00
ECN $0.10 per oz × 10 oz = $1.00 $0.70 $1.70

Example numbers only, to show how to add up costs. Real spreads change by the second and differ by broker and time of day.

The model with the lowest number on paper is not always cheaper in practice. Check real spreads at the hours you trade. Our worked comparison of cent, standard and raw accounts and the gold trading cost calculator help you do this with your own numbers.

Conflicts of interest and the rules

In the EU and UK, investment firms must take “all sufficient steps” to obtain the best possible result for clients when executing orders (best execution under MiFID II, Directive 2014/65/EU, Article 27), and must have policies to manage conflicts of interest. Other strong regulators have similar rules.

That is why the two documents that tell you most about a broker’s model are:

  1. Order execution policy: how and where orders are filled, whether the firm acts as principal (takes the other side) or agent.
  2. Conflicts of interest policy: how the firm manages the incentive to profit from client losses.

An offshore or unregulated broker may say “ECN” on its homepage with no such documents and no regulator to complain to. If something goes wrong, you may have no one to help you. Read how to complain about a broker to see why regulation matters when it does.

8 questions to ask before opening an account

  1. Which regulator licenses the exact company that will hold my account? (Check the regulator’s own register.)
  2. Does the firm act as principal or agent on my gold trades?
  3. Where is the order execution policy, and when was it last updated?
  4. What is the average gold spread at the hours I trade, not the minimum?
  5. What commission is charged per lot, per side or round trip?
  6. What happens to orders during high-impact news: are there requotes, slippage limits, wider margins?
  7. Is there negative balance protection? See negative balance protection.
  8. How long do withdrawals take, and are there fees?

If a broker cannot answer clearly, or the answers change between the website and the legal documents, walk away.

Does the model explain “stop hunting”?

Many traders blame the broker when a stop is hit by a spike. Sometimes the cause is the spread widening (your sell stop on a buy trade is hit by the bid price, which dips further than the chart shows). Sometimes it is a real price spike. A dealing-desk model gives the broker an incentive, but a regulated broker manipulating prices against clients would be breaking the rules. Our guide is my broker stop hunting me? shows how to check with data before deciding.

Key points

  • Market makers take the other side; STP passes orders to liquidity providers; ECN matches orders in a network.
  • A-book means the broker passes your trade on; B-book means it keeps it; many brokers are hybrids.
  • The label “ECN” on an account does not prove how orders are filled. Read the order execution policy.
  • Regulation and withdrawals matter more than the model.
  • Compare total cost (spread plus commission) at the hours you actually trade.

This page is education, not financial advice. We do not recommend or rank any broker. Trading gold CFDs with leverage carries a high risk of loss.

Frequently asked questions

What is the difference between ECN, STP and market maker?

A market maker (dealing desk) takes the other side of your trade itself. An STP broker passes your order straight through to one or more liquidity providers, such as banks. An ECN broker connects your order to a network where many participants’ prices meet. STP and ECN are often called no dealing desk.

What is A-book and B-book?

A-book means the broker passes your trade to an outside liquidity provider and earns from spreads or commission. B-book means the broker keeps your trade on its own books and takes the other side, so it earns when you lose. Many brokers run a hybrid: some clients A-book, others B-book.

Is an ECN broker better for gold?

Not automatically. ECN-style accounts often have tighter raw spreads plus a commission, which can be cheaper for active traders. But regulation, fair execution and easy withdrawals matter more than the label. Check the total cost per trade and the broker’s licence, not the marketing word.

Are market makers bad?

Not necessarily. A regulated market maker must follow rules on fair treatment and best execution, and market makers can offer fixed or stable spreads and fast fills. The risk is the conflict of interest, which is why regulation and a clear order execution policy matter.

How can I tell what kind of broker I have?

Read the broker’s order execution policy and conflicts of interest policy, usually in the legal documents section. They should say whether the firm acts as principal (takes the other side) or as agent (passes orders on). If you cannot find these documents, treat it as a warning sign.

Sources and further reading

External sites are independent of XAUUSD Global. Check dates and data yourself.

Comments

No comments yet.

Leave a comment

Comments are checked before they appear. Be respectful: no promotion, no trade signals. Rules · Privacy. No email needed.