The short answer
Most retail traders lose money on leveraged products such as CFDs, and this is not a rumour: regulators measured it.
- In 2018, the European Securities and Markets Authority (ESMA) said national regulators’ analyses showed that 74-89% of retail CFD accounts typically lose money (ESMA press release, 27 March 2018).
- In 2016, the UK Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) said its review of a sample of client accounts at CFD firms found 82% of clients lost money (FCA press release, 6 December 2016).
- Because of findings like these, EU and UK rules now make every CFD provider show a risk warning with the percentage of its own retail accounts that lose money.
We do not quote any single firm’s figure here. Brokers must publish their own figure; you will see it on their site.
The good news is that the reasons people lose are known, and most of them are under your control. They are covered below, each with a page that shows the fix.
The official rule: what ESMA and the FCA require
Most retail XAUUSD trading is done through a CFD, a contract with a broker that pays the difference in price. If that is new to you, read what is a gold CFD? first.
ESMA, 2018 (European Union)
On 27 March 2018, ESMA announced product intervention measures for CFDs sold to retail clients. They included:
| Measure | What it means in simple words |
|---|---|
| Leverage limits from 30:1 to 2:1 | Gold is capped at 20:1 for retail clients |
| Margin close-out at 50% | The provider must close your positions when your money falls to half the margin needed |
| Negative balance protection | You cannot lose more than the money in your account |
| A restriction on incentives | Limits on bonuses and other rewards offered to make you trade |
| A standardised risk warning | Including the percentage of the provider’s retail accounts that lose money |
Source: ESMA press release, 27 March 2018.
FCA, 2019 (United Kingdom)
The FCA made similar rules permanent in the UK in its policy statement PS19/18, published on 1 July 2019, with the CFD rules in force from 1 August 2019. Firms must limit leverage to between 30:1 and 2:1 depending on the asset, close positions at 50% of required margin, protect clients from a negative balance, stop offering inducements, and show a standardised risk warning that states the percentage of the firm’s retail client accounts that make losses.
Source: FCA PS19/18: Restricting contract for difference products sold to retail clients.
What this means for you
- The percentage you see on a regulated provider’s site is its own figure, for its own clients.
- It is a share of accounts, not a promise about you. But it tells you the odds are not on the side of the average beginner.
- Firms outside the EU and UK rules, including many offshore firms advertised on social media, may show no figure at all and may offer much higher leverage. That does not mean their clients do better.
The five real reasons traders lose (and the fix for each)
1. Too much leverage
Leverage lets you open a big position with a small deposit. It does not make you right more often. It only makes each move bigger.
Example (hypothetical numbers): an account of $1,000, gold at $4,000. On gold, 1 lot = 100 ounces, so a $1 move is worth $100 per lot.
| Position | $1 move | A normal $20 move against you | Share of the account |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.01 lot | $1 | $20 | 2% |
| 0.10 lot | $10 | $200 | 20% |
| 0.50 lot | $50 | $1,000 | 100% |
At 1:500 leverage, opening 0.50 lot needs only $400 of margin, so the app lets you do it. Under ESMA’s 20:1 cap for gold, the same trade would need $10,000 of margin, so you could not open it with $1,000. That is exactly why regulators capped leverage.
The fix: size every trade from the money you are willing to lose, not from the leverage on offer. Read gold leverage explained and use the lot size calculator.
2. No stop-loss (or moving it)
A trade without a stop-loss has no planned exit. A small loss becomes a big one while you “wait for it to come back”. With leverage, that can end at a margin call and stop-out.
The fix: decide the stop before you click, and never move it further away. Our stop-loss calculator guide and how to set SL and TP on MT5 mobile show you how.
3. Overtrading
Gold moves a lot, so there is always something to click. More trades mean more costs, more mistakes and more trades taken out of boredom or anger.
The fix: a short list of setups you trade, a maximum number of trades a day, and a rule to stop after a set loss. Read overtrading gold and when to stop trading for the day.
4. Costs you do not notice
Every trade pays the spread, sometimes a commission, and swap if you hold overnight. One trade’s cost looks tiny. Hundreds add up.
Example (hypothetical numbers): a spread of $0.30 per ounce on 0.10 lot costs $3 per trade. Ten trades a day for 20 days is 200 trades, or $600 a month. On a $1,000 account, that is 60% of the account in costs alone, before any losing trade.
The fix: trade less, and know your real costs. Read spreads, commissions and swaps on gold.
5. Feelings: fear, greed and revenge
After a loss, many traders want to win it back at once and take a bigger trade. After a win, they feel unbeatable and break their rules. Both are normal human reactions, and both cost money.
The fix: written rules, a trading journal, and knowing the patterns. Start with revenge trading and tilt and the trading psychology hub.
How the five reasons work together
Most blown accounts are not one mistake. They are a chain: a big position (1), no stop (2), then a second trade to win it back (5), taken at a bad time with a wide spread (4), again and again (3). Break any link and the damage gets smaller. Break all five and you are trading like a careful professional, even with a small account.
The risk of ruin calculator shows how fast an account can fail when the risk per trade is too high.
What this does not mean
- It does not mean trading is a scam. The market is real. Read is trading real or a scam?.
- It does not mean you will lose. It means the average result is poor, so you should not trade like the average person.
- It does not mean a high-leverage firm without a warning is safer. It usually means fewer protections.
Key points
- Regulators measured it: ESMA cited 74-89% of retail CFD accounts losing (2018); the FCA found 82% in a 2016 sample.
- EU and UK CFD providers must publish their own loss percentage. Look for it on their site.
- The five reasons: leverage, no stop, overtrading, costs and feelings.
- Each has a fix, and all of them are about controlling risk, not finding a magic strategy.
Educational content only, not financial advice. Trading gold with leverage carries a high risk of loss. Figures quoted are from the regulator sources linked, on the dates shown.
Frequently asked questions
What percentage of retail traders lose money?
There is no single official number for all traders. In 2018 the European Securities and Markets Authority said national regulators’ analyses found that 74-89% of retail CFD accounts typically lose money. In 2016 the UK FCA said a sample of client accounts showed 82% of clients lost money. Each provider must now publish its own figure.
Why do CFD brokers show a percentage of losing accounts?
Because EU and UK rules require it. ESMA’s 2018 product intervention measures and the FCA’s rules from 2019 make CFD providers show a standardised risk warning that includes the percentage of their own retail accounts that lose money.
Where can I see a broker's own loss figure?
Regulated EU and UK CFD providers show it in their risk warning, usually at the top or bottom of their website and in their app. Brokers must publish their own figure; you will see it on their site. Firms outside these rules may not show any figure at all.
What is the main reason traders lose money on gold?
Usually a mix of too much leverage and no fixed stop-loss. Gold can move $20 or more in a day, so a position that is too big can wipe out a large part of a small account in one move. Small size and a stop on every trade fix most of the damage.
Can I be in the group that does not lose?
Nobody can promise that. What you can control is your risk: small position sizes, a stop on every trade, few trades, low costs and a written plan. Practise on a demo account first and judge your results over many trades.
Sources and further reading
- CME Group — Gold futures overview — Contract specifications and trading hours for COMEX gold
- CFTC — Commitments of Traders — Weekly futures positioning, including gold
- Investor.gov — Stop order — How stop orders work, and their limits in fast markets
External sites are independent of XAUUSD Global. Check dates and data yourself.
Comments
No comments yet.