The short answer
A prop firm challenge is a paid evaluation. You trade a set account size with a profit target, a daily loss limit and a maximum loss. Pass, sometimes over two phases, and you receive a funded account on which you can request payouts, usually a share of the profit, under the firm’s payout rules. Fail by breaching a loss rule and the fee is gone; some firms sell a reset at a lower price.
Before you pay, work out three numbers: the total cost of the attempts you may need, the gold move your loss limits allow at your size, and how long it takes to reach a first payout.
The stages, one by one
| Stage | What happens | Typical conditions (they vary) |
|---|---|---|
| Purchase | Choose size and type, pay the fee | Fee scales with account size |
| Phase 1 | Reach a profit target | Daily and maximum loss limits; sometimes a time limit and minimum days |
| Phase 2 (two-phase models) | Reach a second, usually lower target | Same loss limits; similar day rules |
| Verification | Identity checks, rule review | Some firms review trades for prohibited strategies here |
| Funded account | Trade for a profit share | Same or similar loss limits; no target; payout rules apply |
| Payouts | Request a share of profit | Minimum days or cycle, consistency rules, payout method |
Some firms sell one-phase evaluations, usually with tighter limits or a trailing drawdown, and some sell three-phase versions. There are also “instant” funded accounts with no evaluation but stricter conditions. Our explainer on what a funded trading account is covers those models.
Profit targets, in gold terms
Hypothetical $10,000 evaluation with a phase 1 target of 8% ($800), a 5% daily loss limit ($500) and a 10% maximum loss ($1,000). One lot of XAUUSD = 100 oz, so $1 = $100 per lot.
| Size | Value of $1 | Gold move to reach $800 | Gold move to lose $500 |
|---|---|---|---|
| 0.10 lot | $10 | $80 net in your favour | $50 against you |
| 0.20 lot | $20 | $40 | $25 |
| 0.50 lot | $50 | $16 | $10 |
The target is never “one trade”. At 0.10 lot it is the sum of many trades, for example eight wins of $15 and four losses of $10: (8 × $15 − 4 × $10) × 10 oz = $800.
The temptation is to go bigger to finish faster. The table shows why that backfires on gold: at 0.50 lot a single $10 move against you uses the whole day’s limit. The prop challenge calculator shows how many losing trades each rule allows at your chosen risk.
Minimum trading days and time limits
- Minimum trading days: you must trade on at least a set number of days before you can pass, even if you hit the target on day one. What counts as a “trading day” (one trade opened, or one trade closed) is defined in the terms.
- Time limits: some phases must be finished within a set number of days. Many firms have removed time limits; others keep them or sell an option to remove them.
- Inactivity: some firms close accounts that go a set period without a trade, including funded accounts.
If there is a time limit, check what happens when it runs out without a breach: some firms give a free retake, others count it as a fail.
Resets, retakes and refunds
- Reset: pay again, usually at a discount, to restart a breached evaluation. It is a new cost.
- Retake: some firms let you restart free if you ran out of time without breaching a loss rule.
- Refund: some firms add the evaluation fee to your first payout. That is a refund only if you reach a payout; failing still costs the full fee.
Count your real cost honestly. If you might need three attempts at $100 each plus one reset at $80, the evaluation costs $380, not $100. Compare that with what you can afford to lose entirely.
How payouts work
When funded, you request payouts under rules that typically cover:
- First payout timing: after a set number of days or trading days from your first funded trade.
- Frequency: a fixed cycle, such as every two weeks or monthly, or on demand once conditions are met.
- Profit share: the percentage of profit paid to you. Some firms raise it over time.
- Conditions: a consistency rule, minimum profitable days, a minimum payout amount, or a review of your trades.
- What happens to the account: after a payout, the paid profit is removed and the balance usually returns to the starting size. Check how the drawdown limit behaves after a payout, especially under trailing rules.
- Method and fees: how you are paid, in which currency, and any charges.
Payout requests are also when many firms run their compliance review. If they find a prohibited strategy, the payout can be refused and the account closed; see what gets a prop account terminated.
Common ways the process goes wrong
- Buying a reset straight after a breach, without changing what caused it.
- Hitting the target before the minimum days and then over-trading to fill the days.
- Missing a time limit by trading too small, or breaching by trading too big to beat it.
- Assuming the funded rules match the evaluation. Some rules, such as news restrictions or consistency, apply only once funded.
- Not reading the payout rules until the first request. Surprises then are expensive.
Questions to answer before you pay
- How many phases, and what are the targets in dollars?
- What are the daily and maximum loss rules, balance or equity, static or trailing?
- Is there a time limit? A minimum number of days? What counts as a day?
- What does a reset cost, and is there a free retake?
- Is the fee refunded, and under what conditions?
- When is the first payout, how often after that, and what is the profit share?
- Which conditions apply to payouts, and what review happens?
- What are gold’s contract size, leverage, lot limits and commission on the firm’s platform?
If you cannot answer all eight from the terms, ask the firm in writing and keep the reply. Then check whether your own trading fits, with the prop challenge readiness checklist, and score the firm with how to choose a prop firm for gold.
Sources
- Contract size: CME Group gold futures contract specifications (100 troy ounces; check your own platform)
- Stage descriptions are a generic summary of common evaluation structures; all figures in the examples are hypothetical and do not describe any firm
Educational content only, not financial advice. We do not recommend any prop firm or evaluation. Evaluation fees are usually lost if you fail. Trading gold with leverage carries a high risk of loss.
Frequently asked questions
What is phase 1 and phase 2 in a prop firm challenge?
In a two-phase evaluation, phase 1 is the first test with a profit target and loss limits, and phase 2 is a second test, usually with a lower profit target and the same loss limits. Passing both leads to a funded account. One-phase evaluations have a single test, often with tighter rules.
What happens if I don't hit the profit target in time?
If the evaluation has a time limit and you have not breached a loss rule, some firms offer a free retake or extension, while others treat the attempt as failed. Many evaluations now have no time limit at all. The terms set out which applies.
What is a challenge reset?
A reset lets you restart a failed or breached evaluation, usually at a lower price than a new one. It returns the account to its starting balance and restarts the phase. It is still a new fee, so count it in your total cost.
How do prop firm payouts work?
Once funded, you request a payout under the firm’s rules, often after a minimum period or number of trading days. The firm checks your trades against its rules, may verify your identity, and pays the agreed share of profit by its stated method. Some firms refund the evaluation fee with the first payout.
Is the challenge fee refundable?
Sometimes, usually only by being added to a later payout, not as a refund if you fail. Read the refund clause, including any conditions such as needing to stay funded for a period.
Comments
No comments yet.